Welcome to Andrew Greeley's Web
Author, Priest, Poet

Blaming Catholics for bigotry is real bias

Blaming Catholics for bigotry is real bias

April 30th, 2008

< Next Article - Previous Article >

in the Chicago SunTimes' Daily Southtown
By Andrew Greeley

nav1.gif (1982 bytes)
Articles
nav2.gif (583 bytes)
Leave Messages
nav3.gif (528 bytes)
About the Author
nav4.gif (545 bytes)
Homilies
nav5.gif (654 bytes)
Preview Novels
nav6.gif (644 bytes)
Mailbox Newsletters
nav7.gif (669 bytes)
Home
nav8.gif (801 bytes)

 Catholic racism in Pennsylvania? Seventy-two percent of Catholic Democrats in the heavily Catholic state of Pennsylvania voted for Sen. Hillary Clinton, according to the MSNBC exit polls, and more than half of them said they would not vote for Sen. Barack Obama if he won the nomination. The finding gave me a chill. On the other hand, most Obama voters said they would vote for Clinton if she should win the contest. Is Catholic racism rearing its ugly head again?

  I have spent almost a half century monitoring Catholic attitudes in this country. Through the years, Catholics have been ahead of Protestant denominations though behind Jews in measures of racial tolerance and on liberal issues -- including the Vietnam war.

  What is happening? Chris Matthews, a native of the Keystone State (poor dear man!), pointed out that many of them might be in neighborhoods where they felt threatened. Abortion does not seem to be an issue in this election, and not many Catholics shape their vote on this issue. Obama did very well in his home city and state among Catholics. Sure it's his home state, but threatened people in such a state might view him as not only a black oppressor but a traitor. That certainly was not the case.

  The media commentators operate in a world of cliches and stereotypes -- "blue collar Catholics," "ethnic Catholics," "Reagan Republican Catholics." Either these labels are false or, charitably interpreted, misleading. At their worst, they are exercises in bigotry.

Keep in touch...
Locally, and Globally! 
Read On
Check out
Andrew M. Greeley's Columns for the
Chicago SunTimes'
Daily Southtown
.

00spc.gif (820 bytes)

  Irish Catholics crossed the line of national college attendance in the first decade of the last century, Polish and Italian Catholics after World War II. Catholics now are above the national average in white-collar and professional class occupations. Some of us are showing up on elite university faculties. Some even on television news programs. There are, of course, many Catholics still in blue-collar jobs, perhaps especially in uncivilized places like Philadelphia and Boston. Yet on average Catholics are disproportionately in the middle, upper middle, and even upper levels of American society. It is not Civil War time, and Catholics are not struggling for jobs with blacks as they did in the New York riots.

  Research by two first-rate sociologists, Clem Brooks and Jeff Manza, has demonstrated that Catholics remained disproportionately Democrats in the Reagan years, not shifting more than anyone else. It is time to stop using "blue-collar" as a routine descriptor for Catholics. Yet many Democratic leaders are embarrassed to admit that they need Catholic votes to win an election. They are somehow unclean.

  It turns out that the three-fifths of Jewish and Protestant Democrats in Pennsylvania also voted against Obama. Is it white racial prejudice in Pennsylvania?

  When the Clintons go around telling people that Obama cannot win, they mean a black candidate cannot be elected. The country isn't ready for an African-American president. That's playing the race card as a trump.

  Will the general election be decided by bigotry? I've wondered that ever since the senator announced. I'm still not convinced that the votes are out there. Bigotry never goes away.

  There is an irony in the fire in this election. Obama's emphasis on community building, learned in organization work on Chicago's Southeast Side with many Catholic parishes, is quintessentially ours, though I don't think he necessarily learned it from us. 

Securely purchase Andrew Greeley's New book - click here!

A Stupid, Unjust, And Criminal War: Iraq 2001-2007
A Stupid, Unjust, And Criminal War: Iraq 2001-2007
Father Greeley calls to task those who justified, planned and executed the war and reminds us that God weeps at the destruction of war, whether lives lost are ‘ours’ or ‘theirs.’
Order Book
Read Reviews

Read the Introduction
Larger Image of Cover

Press Release

Read Father Greeley's latest Articles: 
dot.gif (44 bytes) Why won't Bush admit mistakes?          dot.gif (44 bytes) Bush not swayed by Iraq reality
dot.gif (44 bytes) True or false: Can Bush tell difference?   dot.gif (44 bytes) A church 'scandal' that isn't.
dot.gif (44 bytes)
Suddenly, greed doesn't look good         dot.gif (44 bytes) Bush's cloak-and-stagger folly.
dot.gif (44 bytes)
Bumbling CIA's failures hurt America      dot.gif (44 bytes) Will we betray our Iraqi workers?
dot.gif (44 bytes) Better bishops would be a blessing        dot.gif (44 bytes) Immigration 'win' is no victory
dot.gif (44 bytes)
Caution made JFK a great leader           dot.gif (44 bytes) Ethnic biases stronger than ever           
dot.gif (44 bytes) Latest Bush Iraq plan will fail                 dot.gif (44 bytes) An ending with no meaning
dot.gif (44 bytes)
Long war' plan short on substance         dot.gif (44 bytes) Hatred of immigrants is sinful

Read the Chicago SunTimes' Daily Southtown articles.

Contact Father Greeley

More New Articles

Rapture
Articles | Messages | Author | Homilies | Previews | Mailbox Newsletters | Home

 

Andrew M. Greeley © 1995-'08
All Rights Reserved
Questions & Comments: Webmaster